Reportr.net
Making sense of the intersection between media, society and technology
BBCNews.com readers criticise 'stuck on' ads
In: BBC|advertising|journalism
6 Nov 2007
International readers have been seeing more ads on the BBC News website. (Click on the image for a larger version).
The comments on the BBC Editors blog offer a snapshot of reaction from readers to the advertising.
Some have commented on the clumsy way the ads have been integrated into the site:
- “I don’t mind ads on websites but hopefully your web designers can learn to place them in a way which is not so intrusive.”
- “I doubt very much that you would add any other feature to your carefully designed site the careless way that you seem to have chucked the ads in.”
- “The ads completely dominate the page and totally distract from the content. They look simply ‘stuck on’ – as if a graphic designer wasn’t involved in the process.”
- “While it may be a necessary business decision, you really ought to get some of your design people working on a much better execution of said necessary evil.”
No doubt many at the BBC share these sentiments and would have liked to have redesigned the website to better integrate the ads.
Technorati Tags: BBC, BBCNews.com, advertising
Site Search Tags: BBC, BBCNews.com, advertising
- Tags: BBCNews.com
Comment Form
About this blog
This blog is run by Professor Alfred Hermida, an award-winning online news pioneer, digital media scholar and journalism educator.
- JORNALICES | Jerónimo blogging about Media & Journalism: [...] Journalists value writing but not multimedia skills (tags: journalism multimedia routines icpd [...]
- Journal Register Rethinks News » Newspaper Death Watch: [...] role of the journalist is as aggregator and authenticator rather than original reporter. Quoti [...]
- Journal Register Rethinks News » Newspaper Death Watch: [...] role of the journalist is as aggregator and authenticator rather than original reporter. Quoti [...]
- Best free website development tools?: [...] Five free SEO tools to improve your search rankings [...] [...]
- This Week in Review: Gizmodo and the shield law, making sense of social data, and the WSJ’s local push | Mark Coddington: [...] conference included presentations on all kinds of stuff like Wikipedia, news site design, o [...]
- How the BBC developed its UK election coverage online
- IAMCR 2010 talk on journalism education at UBC
- Journalists value writing but not multimedia skills
- The challenges journalists face covering innovation
- Five free SEO tools for journalists
- Teaching Twitter in journalism schools
- How people love but worry about social media
- Pew Internet on how media habits have changed since 2000
- How news of the Canadian earthquake broke on Twitter
- Word clouds of official G20 messages
No Responses to BBCNews.com readers criticise 'stuck on' ads
links for 2007-11-12 « David Black
November 11th, 2007 at 6:21 pm
[...] BBCNews.com readers criticise ’stuck on’ ads – Reportr.net “I doubt very much that you would add any other feature to your carefully designed site the careless way that you seem to have chucked the ads in.” (tags: internet advertising webdesign bbc) [...]
Debby
November 13th, 2007 at 2:48 pm
Maybe in the US, we are so inundated with advertising that we become just a bit oblivious, but I did not notice any change.
Mike Jones
November 19th, 2007 at 8:08 am
Hi,
I don’t object to ads, but the ad-space at the top of the page disrupts one of the best laid out and integrated page structures to be found anywhere on the web today. Put the ads down the right hand side or at the bottom.
If ads are the price to keep such a resource available, that’s a small price. Many of my colleagues have the BBC as their home page because of its quality and the BBC’c reputation. You are truly a global asset and although your primary responsibility is to the UK, you have a moral responsibility, IMHO, to keep the candle burning in the dark.
thanks and rgds
Mike
Allister
November 20th, 2007 at 12:57 pm
I fervently hope that the BBC website doesn’t end up being on a par with BBC America on TV here in the US. That is mostly utter rubbish, cluttered with commercials and mindless shows such as “Cash in the Attic” or endless old repeats.
I’d happily pay a fee to have an ad-free BBC website and access to more Radio 5 live programs (I’ve noticed these are becoming more and more restricted to international users).
Ironically, I’d been happy enough with ads on other websites I visit. When I saw the mess the BBC had made of their site, I finally got around to downloading an ad blocker. So now I don’t see any ads on the BBC pages, just a mildly irritating blank area at the top. I left it so all the other sites I visit get their ads seen by me, just not the BBC. Kind of defeats the purpose, don’t you think?
Jon
December 13th, 2007 at 11:40 pm
Allister
Yes, prompted by the BBC’s vandalism of its own site, I was prompted to get an ad-blocker too: the one I have actually collapses the blank area where the ad would go, so that the site appears exactly like it did before!
Steve
December 19th, 2007 at 1:05 pm
But, I live and work in the UK, and I can see the ads when I’m at work.
So, the software that determines where the viewer is situated isn’t that accurate then is it?
filthish
December 20th, 2007 at 11:56 am
Ads for overseas readers? Well, yeah, ok – I can see why the Beeb want to do that and it’s fair enough.
But, the positioning, the white-space balance and the nature of the ads! Appauling. It’s a kin to having an inflatable sofa and a mini-fridge installed in the Louvre.
Sort it out BBC!
elvis
March 17th, 2008 at 6:39 am
Well, i see little wrong with the ads on the bbc site.
Ken
December 22nd, 2009 at 10:59 am
I hate these ads on the BBC website because they slow the site down. It used to load instantly but now there is a pause of several seconds during which the page is white.
Also I keep getting an ad with a picture of a sweaty Lance Armstrong on it, which is actually pretty offensive. If you were reading a newspaper and someone kept sticking a picture of a sweaty Lance Armstrong in front of your face every time you turn a page wouldn’t you eventually want to punch them?